WINTER 1999
Table of Contents
Chair's column
Judy Cook obituary
Resolutions
OHS Section Committee Reports:
Workers Compensation
Scholarship committee
OH Nurses subcommittee report
AIHA seeks participants
Health Provider language in OSHA standards
Awards nominations sought
Next section newsletter publication deadlines
Section web information
NIOSH Safety & Health training conference announcement
Scholarship letter and application
Leadership roster
--------------------------------------------------
From the Section Chair - Thomas Robins
OH&S Section Continues Advocacy for Social Change
A heartfelt welcome to 1999 from the Occupational Health & Safety Section. First, I want to thank Mary Miller for her incredible energy and dedication as Chair this past year and continued hard work while we transition into the current year. Among her major accomplishments was the launching of the excellent OHS section Web page with the assistance of Morley Slutsky and Emily Allen. The Web page address is http://www.staff.washington.edu/oshalert. You can also link to it from the APHA home page at http://www.apha.org under the "Sections" location. Check it out!
We have a great leadership roster this year and the section tradition of advocacy for social change and activism continues. One thing I have been struck with as I have become increasingly familiar with the work of the section is its focus and enthusiasm which leads the influence beyond our moderate membership numbers. This is reflected in the substantial number of APHA resolutions sponsor co-sponsored by our section which have been adopted. Recent examples include the passage of a resolution on Ergonomics at the 1997 meeting and an end to the use of carcinogens as fuel additives in the 1998 meeting. Once a resolution is passed it essentially becomes part of APHA policy, the weight of the organization can be called upon when needed in support of the issue addressed by the resolution. We can use the policies in our local settings as well as on the national level to fight for better working conditions.
Our influence is felt throughout the organization and nationally. Two of our section members have moved into nationally prominent positions during this past year. David Michaels has been appointed as Assistant Secretary, for Environment, Safety and Health, U.S. Department Of Energy.. Andrea Taylor has been appointed to the newly created U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board. Key positions held by section members within APHA include Barry Levy, as a recent President of APHA, David Michaels as Chair of the Action Board, and Howie Frumkin as Chair of the Science Board, to name a few. We and many other active Section members, are available to promote better working conditions through efforts to change policies at the national level, as well as in our local communities. Please use us as resources and consider becoming more involved yourself. We have a number very active committees within the section with which you may wish to work. Some examples include the occupational health nursing, industrial hygiene, young workers, workers compensation, maquiladora, and the scholarship committees. See that enclosed section leadership roster for contact numbers.
An important focus for us in the coming year will be to recruit new members. It is incumbent upon all of us to find ways to tell others, especially students, about the important work we do in occupational health and safety, and why APHA is an important avenue for policy and worker advocacy to take place. We are working closely with the Public Health Student Caucus of APHA to identify and connect with new members. Many of our more 'seasoned' section members have become active in a mentoring project in which they are actively linking with students and other new members. If you would like to act as a mentor please contact Derrick Hodge, Mary Miller, or Linda Murray.
As usual, our section was highly visible at the APHA meeting held this past November in Washington, D.C.. The OHS section is sponsored or co-sponsored over 40 sessions and other events. Some highlights of the program included a memorial for Meta Snyder, a very active member of the section and occupational health nurse who died recently of AIDS contracted from a workplace needlestick injury. Our awards luncheon honored the accomplishments of four of our colleagues: - for the Alice Hamilton Award (lifetime accomplishment to promote occupational health and safety), Denny Dobbin, architect of the NIEHS Asbestos Abatement and Hazardous Waste Workers Training Programs;- for the Lorin Kerr Award (recognition of a health and safety activist), Garrett Brown, coordinator of the Maquiladora Health Project and Cal/OSHA inspector; - and for the International Award (recognition of health and safety accomplishments by an individual or group based outside the United States), Mohamed Jeebhay, South African physician and researcher long active serving the black trade union movement, and Rory O'Neill, editor of the Workers' Health International Newsletter (WHIN).
An important ongoing activity of our section, working together with the Labor Caucus,
is to influence APHA to choose unionized hotels whenever possible for meetings as well as
union labor for construction projects. At this past Annual Meeting, much to our
disappointment, our own section was located in a non-union hotel. We are working with
APHA's Executive Board to promote adoption of a policy to require negotiation of
neutrality agreements between APHA and the hotel chain in the event that non union hotels
must be used for meetings. These agreements require the employer to refrain from
interference in its employees right to organize. I will keep you posted on progress with
this.
Judy Cook Obituary
By Kathy Kirkland
Judy Ann Cook passed away on December 31, 1998 at University Hospital in London, Ontario, at the age of 57 after a courageous and lengthy wait for a heart transplant. Judy is survived by her beloved son, Adam Hannibal.
Judy was an active member of the occupational health section of APHA and served on the Board of Directors of the Association of Occupational and Environmental Clinics. At the time of her death, she was the Executive Director of the Manitoba Federation of Labour Occupational Health Centre. Judy graduated from the University of Michigan with a degree in Political Science. The social activism that is Judy's legacy began with her involvement in the civil rights movement and other social causes. Moving to Winnipeg in 1975, Judy continued her work to improve the quality of life for others through her involvement with community health care, workplace health and safety and the labor movement.
Judy was representative of a number of non-medical professionals in APHA. Her name was not seen on presentations, she did not author epidemiological papers but her hard work made it possible for others to do that work. Columnist Doug Smith stated in the Winnipeg Free Press on January 4, 1999, "I don't think I saw Judy's name in the paper more than one or two times. She was a passionate fighter for worker health, but she never sought the limelight. She believed that her job was to help workers organize to save their lives - not to ride in on a charger and save them. Judy's example, particularly to those of us with more swollen egos, was always chastening." Judy worked with the public health and occupational health communities on both sides of the border to ensure a safe and healthy working environment regardless of nationality.
Memorial donations may be made to the Multi Organ Transplant Unit, University Hospital, 339 Windermere Road, PO Box 5339, London, Ontario, N6A 5A5; the Occupational Health Centre, 275 Broadway, Winnipeg, MB R3C 4M6or the Mary Beth Dolin Fund, c/o Manitoba NDP, 98 Sherbrook Street, Winnipeg, MB R3C 2B3.
By Jim Cone
APHA resolutions are policy statements of the organization that guide the staff in responding to issues and initiatives, for example, in Congress. The OH&S Section Resolutions Committee proposed two resolutions which were passed by the Governing Council in 1998(1) Preventing adverse environmental effects and safety hazards of "light trucks', and (2) Preventing adverse occupational and environmental consequences of MTBE in fuels. In addition, we supported a late breaker on Full disclosure of federal research and policies on multiple chemical sensitivity needed to evaluate new research priorities and policies.
We are now soliciting ideas for needed policy for APHA over the next few years. Potential resolutions in the process of being drafted include
1. Health effects of diesel exhaust. Contact: Jim Cone at jcone@igc.org
2. Requiring safer needles to prevent transmission of HIV, HBV and HCV to health care workers. Contact: June Fisher at TDICTPROJ@aol.com.
3. Expanding APHA existing policy on occupational health and social effects of sweatshop labor. Contact: Craig Slatin at Craig_Slatin@uml.edu
The resolutions are due March 5th at APHA Headquarters. If you would like to get some guidance and/or assistance in writing a resolution (<500 words), contact Jim Cone at 510-845-7398 (h) or jcone@igc.org.
Workers Compensation Committee
By Glenn Shor, Ph.D.
Workers' compensation continues to be a controversial area, and many members of the occupational health and safety section are either directly or indirectly involved in some aspect of the various state and federal systems. Members of the workers' compensation committee met twice at the Washington annual meeting. In the coming year, the committee wishes to concentrate on at least some of the following priority areas: Privacy of medical records; the process, fairness and outcomes of independent medical examinations; issues around retaliatory discharge after reporting of work injuries, and other barriers to access of workers' compensation system; evaluation of return to work programs; injury reports and surveillance systems for the identification and understanding of workplace injury trends; and issues around the use of guides for the evaluation of permanent impairment and disability. The committee plans to work with the program committee to create a series of sessions (a workers' compensation track) for next year's APHA conference in Chicago; to review prior policy resolutions of the APHA as they refer to workers' compensation, and to consider the drafting of resolutions for next year; participating in or doing some type of interstate/interprovincial comparison of jurisdictions on various aspects of workers' compensation important to section members; and organizing ourselves for action by creating or participating in e-mail lists, listservers, and web sites. The subcommittee is also interested in ways to piggyback analyses of economic and social outcomes of workplace injuries on existing studies in the occupational health and safety area.
Those interested in contributing to any of these projects, or wants to get on the committee e-mailing list should contact Glenn Shor gshor@hq.dir.ca.gov.
Scholarship Committee Plans for APHA Meeting in Boston
By Janie Gordon, ScM.
The Section's new Scholarship Committee met at the Annual Meeting in D.C. and announces the availability of scholarships for the 1999 Annual Meeting. The pilot plan is to offer two $300.00 scholarships; one to a student and one to a union representative. The scholarship applications are included this newsletter. Applications are due May 1st.
We will also spearhead a campaign for Section members who have their APHA expenses covered by work to donate $10.00 to the scholarship fund when they register next year! More details to follow...
If you'd like to participate on the committee please email Janie Gordon jgordon@umppa1.ab.umd.edu or telephone 410-706-7464
The Occupational Health Nurses Committee
By Kate McPhaul, RN, MPH
The committee met 11/16/98 and agreed work to connect with nurses in the Public Health Nursing and Environment sections as well as liaison with the Association of Occupational and Environmental Clinics, OSHA, American Association of Occupational Health Nurses and the American Nurses Association.
Issues of interest to the committee members include hearing about and working toward implementation of the Institute of Medicine recommendations for integrating
occupational/environmental content into nursing practice, education and research. Jane Lipscomb and Barbara Sattler reported on their efforts at the University of Maryland School of Nursing. They will soon have a webpage for resources for educators.
The committee also agreed to study and discuss the issues of confidentiality of medical records at the workplace and be active on needlestick prevention activities. The committee is also considering naming itself after Meta Snyder a former chairperson of this committee and active occupational health nurse who recently died of AIDS.
The members expressed interest in a listserve forum for communicating with each other; while this option is being investigated please contact Kate McPhaul at (410) 706-1837 or email kmcphaul@umppa1.ab.umd.edu if you would like to be on the mailing list.
AIHA (ASC Z9) Seeks New Members
By Margaret Breida (
mbreida@aiha.org), Scientific Affairs Associate, AIHAThe American Industrial Hygiene Association holds the Secretariat for the Accredited Standards Committee Z9, Safety Standards for Exhaust Systems. OHS Section member Howard Ayer, APHA's representative to the Z9 committee since 1980, has recently retired from the committee. Howard has done a great job over the years and we are hoping that someone from the OHS Section will be interested in following in his footsteps. Representatives from other labor organizations or individual members are also welcome.
The committee is charged with developing and maintaining standards for the design, operation and maintenance of equipment to provide a safe atmosphere in industrial, manufacturing or construction operations by removing harmful substances by either local exhaust or general ventilation and safely disposing of such substances, and such supplementary standards on personal protection as may be necessary to prescribe methods for the protection of workers. Suggestions for new standards under this scope are also welcome.
The Committee usually meets at AIHCE (AIHA's annual meeting -- June 5-11, 1999 in Toronto) and holds a mid-year meeting at AIHA Headquarters (Fairfax, VA). Please contact Lindsay Cook, AIHA (ASC Z9) Chair (ph: 919-558-1325, e-mail: lcook@ciit.org) or Margie Breida at AIHA (ph: 703-849-8888, e-mail: mbreida@aiha.org) to volunteer.
Health Care Provider Language in OSHA Standards
By Katherine Kirkland, Mary Miller, Drew Brodkin, and Anita Schill
Due to the overwhelming number of activities at APHA there isn't time to attend every session. The panel "Issues in Occupational Health Care" encompassed a number of
clinical issues, such as industrial hygienists in clinics, quality assurance in occupational medicine, medical record confidentiality and is a productive forum for dialogue on issues which affect occupational health professionals and, ultimately, workers themselves. There was also a very timely discussion of interest to clinicians providing medical and health surveillance services to workers. Mary Miller, responding to concerns raised at APHA in 1997 brought together a multidisciplinary panel to discuss the controversial issue of appropriate providers of medical surveillance for occupational health surveillance.
OSHA, represented by Adam Finkel, Director of Health Standards, believes that the use of broad-based health care professional language in its medical surveillance provisions will provide workers with the maximum possible access to professionals with advanced education and training in understanding, and distinguishing between organic and exposure-related adverse health conditions. OSHA has used the term "physician or other licensed health care professional (LHCP)" in its most recent health standards, which is defined as "an individual whose legally permitted scope of practice...allows him or her to independently provide or be delegated the responsibility to provide some or all of the health care services required...." Additionally, OSHA believes the authority to determine the scope of practice for health care professionals belongs to the States. This language represents a performance-oriented, cost-effective approach that recognized the needs of workers, employers and health care professionals.
Mary Miller, in support of the broad-based language, advanced the notion that, depending on the State, nurse practitioners have independent authority to diagnose and prescribe medications and therefore are sufficiently qualified to supervise occupational health surveillance programs without physician oversight. She feels strongly that those who manage occupational health surveillance programs have the requisite occupational health knowledge and experience.
Drew Brodkin, spoke as both an occupational physician and as a representative of the Association of Occupational and Environmental Clinics (AOEC). He too felt that competence and experience of the occupational provider is an essential component. However, he would like language recommending or requiring that an occupational physician be available for consultation in the case of abnormal findings requiring follow-up and for establishing the surveillance protocols. He cited the Methylene Chloride standard as a standard with sufficient complexity to warrant this provision. He reiterated the AOEC position that all health care providers involved in the implementation of any OSHA standard, including licensed physicians, have an ethical responsibility to ensure that they are both prepared and qualified to discharge their responsibilities in occupational health in a professional and knowledgeable manner prior to assuming that responsibility.
Adam Finkel reported that the American College of Occupational and Environmental
Physician's (ACOEM) has sued OSHA to change the broad-based language as it exists in the revised Respiratory Protection standard and delete the clause "other licensed health care professional". The American Medical Association joined as a party to the suit supporting ACOEM's position. The Association of Occupational Health Nurses and the American Nurses Association have countersued to retain the proposed language which includes LHCP.
Anita Schill, also of OSHA's Health Standards, extended an open invitation to the audience for suggestions on how to improve the present broad-based language for health care professional and which criteria, if any, should be used to assess proficiency to provide the required medical surveillance components. Suggestions may be sent to either Anita or Adam (200 Constitution Avenue, N.W., Room N-3718, Washington, D.C. 20210).
Time restrictions forced an early end to the discussion, however, the presentations provided a much needed factual basis for a timely professional discussion in spite of on-going disagreements about the current language.
Awards
By Darius D. Sivin, MES
Nominations for awards to be presented at the 1999 APHA annual meeting are now open. As always, there are three categories:
Please submit nominations to Darius Sivin at
dsivin@jhsph.edu (see the contact list above for phone and address) or other members of the Awards Committee. While we are a relatively small community, we dont all know the good works of everyone in our field. So please include a little information (a paragraph or two) about the good deeds of your nominee.Section Newsletter submission deadlines
We plan to put out two more newsletter this year. (Just so you know, APHA takes up to 6
weeks to get the final newsletter into the mail after we submit our completed text.) For
the summer issue, articles must be submitted to the section by May 7th and will
arrive to members in mid June. For the fall issue, articles must be submitted by July 26th
and will arrive to members before the conference. Submit articles to Maggie Robbins by
e-mail (WordPerfect, rtf or plain text format, please) at mrobbins@wiggle.sf.ca.us.
Web information
APHA web site: http://www.apha.org
Occupational Health Section web site can be reached through the APHA site, or you can go directly to it at: http://staff.washington.edu/oshalert
OSHALERT is our section e-mail distribution list to communicate timely information regarding important legislation and action alerts. To subscribe, send an email to: oshalert@umich.edu
Contact information for the APHA Virtual Conference Project: Occupational Health Section Pilot: Michael Davies: mdavies@neuron.uchc.edu, 860-679-1869 or Tim Morse: 860-679-4720.
The Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees website for find out where the union hotels are throughout the U.S.: http://www.hereunion.com
NIOSH Conference on Workplace Safety and Health Training
By Deborah Weinstock
Save these dates October 24-26, 1999 for the National Conference on Workplace Safety and Health Training Henry VIII Hotel and Conference Center, St. Louis, Missouri.
Sponsored by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. Co-sponsored by Occupational Safety and Health Administration and the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences. Assisted by the Society for Public Health Education
This participatory conference will bring together cross-sector interests to improve the safety and health of workers, and shape the training and education programs of the 21st century.
For further information on this conference call, 404-633-6477; e-mail:
s_baun@psava.com or go to the NIOSH web site, http://www.cdc.gov/niosh
Occupational Health & Safety Section
Occupational Health & Safety Section Scholarship Fund
American Public Health Association
The Occupational Health and Safety Section will be awarding two scholarships which include registration for the 1999 APHA Annual Meeting (November 7 - 11, 1999, Chicago, Illinois), a one year membership in APHA and $200.00 for conference expenses. The purpose of the fund is to strengthen the participation of students and union representatives in APHA. We recognize that we need the involvement of workers and new health & safety professionals to make our workplaces & communities healthy and safe.
AWARD:
The value of each award is over $300.00. The Section will directly pay the annual meeting fee & one year membership to APHA with primary membership in the Occupational Health & Safety Section. Each awardee will then receive $200.00 which can be used to cover transportation, lodging, and meals. Awardees will be responsible for providing the remainder of funds necessary to cover these expenses. At the Annual Meeting we will pair each awardee with a section member with similar interests.
ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS:
Students
Student applicants should be enrolled in a graduate-level program which can lead to work in the occupational health & safety field. (Examples include medicine, nursing, public health, toxicology, law, industrial hygiene, safety, ergonomics)
Union Representatives
Union representatives should have some health & safety responsibilities.
(Examples include local union officers, health & safety committee members, shop stewards, & district-level officers and representatives). These awards are NOT intended for international union health & safety staff.
Please submit your application by May 1, 1999 to:
Janie Gordon, ScM.
University of Maryland School of Medicine
Occupational Health Project
405 W. Redwood, 2nd Floor
Baltimore, MD 21201
Direct questions to Janie Gordon:
Telephone: 410-706-7464
Email: jgordon@umppa1.ab.umd.edu
THIS APPLICATION FORM CAN BE REPRODUCED!
Occupational Health & Safety Section
American Public Health Association
Scholarship Fund Application : FOR STUDENTS
Please print or type:
Name: _________________________________________________________________
Street Address:___________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________
City, State, Zip __________________________________________________________
Telephone: Day (____)____________________________________________________
Evening (____)____________________________________________________
Fax (____)____________________________________________________
Email __________________________________________________________
************************************************************************
Name of University_______________________________________________________
University City, State, Zip __________________________________________________
Degree Program: _________________________________________________________
Field of Interest _________________________________________________________
Please complete the following information for a faculty member we can contact as a reference:
Name ____________________________________________________________
Telephone (____)___________________________________________________
Email __________________________________________________________
Optional :
Sex: _______________
Ethnic Background: _________________________
Please answer the following questions. (You can add additional pages if you need to, but a concise response is welcomed.)
Submit applications by May 1, 1999 to: Direct questions to:
Janie Gordon, ScM. Telephone: 410-706-7464
University of Maryland School of Medicine
Occupational Health Project
405 W. Redwood, 2nd Floor
Baltimore, MD 21201
Email: jgordon@umppa1.ab.umd.edu
THIS APPLICATION FORM CAN BE REPRODUCED!
Occupational Health & Safety Section
American Public Health Association
Scholarship Fund Application : FOR UNION REPRESENTATIVES
Please print or type:
Name: _________________________________________________________________
Street Address:___________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________
City, State, Zip __________________________________________________________
Telephone: Day (____)____________________________________________________
Evening (____)____________________________________________________
Fax (____)____________________________________________________
Email __________________________________________________________
************************************************************************
Union Name (with local,district#) __________________________________________
Union Street Address _________________________________________________
Union City, State, Zip __________________________________________________
Your Position within Union (member, steward, officer, health & safety committee member): _________________________________________________________
Optional :
Sex: _______________
Ethnic Background: _________________________
Please answer the following questions. (You can add additional pages if you need to, but a concise response is welcomed.)
Submit applications by May 1, 1999 to: Direct questions to:
Janie Gordon, ScM. Telephone: 410-706-7464
University of Maryland School of Medicine
Occupational Health Project
405 W. Redwood, 2nd Floor
Baltimore, MD 21201
Email: jgordon@umppa1.ab.umd.edu